Why Do Some Faces Become More Interesting With Age?

Black and white portrait of a grey-haired woman with expressive features resting her chin on her hand

Imagine two faces.

The first is young, almost perfectly smooth. The second has wrinkles, strong features and a gaze that is hard to forget. Which one will you call more beautiful, and which one will seem more interesting to you? These are not the same question, although we usually pretend they are.

Beauty and uniqueness are not the same thing

In 2018, a team led by psychologist Natalie Ebner studied how people judge faces of different ages. It turned out that young and middle-aged participants rated older faces as more distinctive than young ones, even after accounting for differences in attractiveness.

So a face does not have to match the ideals of beauty to draw attention. Sometimes it is precisely its individual features that make it interesting. A smooth face is easy to confuse with ten other smooth faces. The one with a furrow between the brows is not.

A curious fact: is a caricature better than a photograph?

Did you know that people can sometimes recognise a caricature faster than a faithful portrait of the same person?

In psychological experiments, researchers found that emphasising the distinctive features of a face can make it easier to recognise. An enlarged nose, pronounced cheekbones or unusual proportions become cues for our brain.

It is a fascinating property of human memory: the most faithful image is not always the easiest one to recognise.

Wrinkles say less than we think

We like to believe that wrinkles are a record of life: that you can read from a face who laughed a lot and who worried a lot. Research shows something less romantic.

In 2015, a team of researchers tested how we read emotions from older faces. It turned out that wrinkles and folds make facial expressions harder to recognise: a calm, neutral face of an older person was more often perceived as full of emotion, while real emotions got lost among the features.

An older face is therefore more expressive, but not at all more legible. These are two different things, and we confuse them every day when we judge people at first glance.

Does elegance have no age?

A study published in 2021 showed that the age of a face affects judgements of beauty more strongly than judgements of elegance. Older faces received lower attractiveness ratings on average, but age played a much smaller role when elegance was being judged.

Appearance, then, is something more complex than the mere pursuit of youth. You can stop being “pretty” and only then start being elegant.

Uniqueness instead of perfection

In youth, we often pay attention to smooth skin and the proportions of a face. Over time, however, some faces gain something else, more recognisable, unrepeatable features.

Perhaps that is why a good portrait does not always show a person with ideal proportions. Painters have known this for a long time: Rembrandt painted his own face for forty years, from a young man to an old one, and the most moving are the late self-portraits, full of furrows and shadows. Sometimes the most interesting face is the one we would never mistake for any other.

Beauty can catch the eye. But a distinctive look can arouse curiosity.

Sources: Ebner et al. (2018), An Adult Developmental Approach to Perceived Facial Attractiveness and Distinctiveness, Frontiers in Psychology; Benson and Perrett (1994), Visual Processing of Facial Distinctiveness, Perception; Freudenberg, Adams, Kleck and Hess (2015), Through a Glass Darkly: Facial Wrinkles Affect Our Processing of Emotion in the Elderly, Frontiers in Psychology; He et al. (2021), The Effect of Aging on Facial Attractiveness, Acta Psychologica.